
I am writing this article with great grievance. This article is not at all meant to degrade the Institute, but to make the educators realize that their approach towards the education system at the Institute is detrimental for the current students.
I am an IoBM graduate and it really hurts me to see the Institute going down every year. I joined IoBM in the year 2002, during those years there were only two blocks (buildings). There was no Students Activity Centre, there was no Examination building, Mosque was half of its present area, there were no cameras installed, less security checks and a lot other things that didnt exist during those times. Contrary to this there were better teachers, students were more serious towards study, less cheating cases, ease of registration, etc.
For all the things that I have mentioned above, I will blame no one except the Board which includes Mr. Shah Jehan Karim, Mr. Talib Karim and Ms. Sabina Mohsin. It is because of their short-sighted vision they couldnt achieve horizon. They went upwards during their first years but couldnt sustain, then comes the downfall against the Institutes like Szabist, Iqra University, Muhammad Ali Jinnah University and Lahore School of Economics.
In my opinion, following are the reasons behind the downfall of the Institute.:
Commercial Mindedness:
An Institute can never be successful if the motive behind is to make. A good example is of The City School and now IoBM. The Board claims the IoBM business as Non-Profit Organization, but my friends Non-Profit Organization does not at all means that there is no profit. My accounting friends would agree to this point that when making Profit & Loss, Non-Profit Organizations use the term surplus instead of profit. The profit still exists and it is distributed among the owners. Believe it or not I saw tremendous change in the “family’s” attire, arrogance, protocol, approach and lastly their cars. How many of you would believe that Director Academics used to have a small car? It is justified to uplift and keep up your profile, but it is not at all justified to fill your pockets at the cost of students’ future.
Quality of Education:
Quality of education is a principle responsibility of any Institute. Quality does not comes from qualification, it comes from competence, dedication, passion and determination. The excellence in education cannot be achieved by hiring cheap teachers. Low cost teachers with none of the above qualitative variables will make the students Lakeer ka Fakeer, which is not the aim of any Institute. Invest in your teachers and groom them. Once the Dean of IoBM told his story of hiring a teacher: Dean called one of his known student for some economics course. After discussing the details of the course, Dean’s student asked how much will the Institute pay as salary? Dean with embarrassment quoted Rs. 40,000, the student smiled and said sorry Sir, I am earning much more than this. Dean concluded by saying that IoBM doesnt pay good at all and I have confirmed this with many teachers who used to and are currently teaching over there.
Out of Focus Approach:
I did my Intermediate from Commecs college in 2002. The college was famous for Commerce students as it was founded by old students of Government Commerce College (a reputable college of that time). Commecs was famous for its strictness and affiliation with Institute of Business Administration. One year after I passed out, they started diversifying, which I believe was the turning point. They started Engineering and Computer Sciences, something they were not holding any ability. The downfall came hurt the overall image of the College.
Same happened with IoBM. They started good with BBA and MBA, but as said above, when the money started to flow someone suggested to diversify. Need not to mention, the downfall started. If you are not focussed how can you be successful? Teachers of IoBM taught us by examples.
Criteria of a Good Institute:
If you ever get a chance to read the catalogue of IoBM you will see on what basis they claim their institute to be better than other Institutes. I have attended three convocations and in each convocation either Mr. Talib Karim or Mr. Shah Jehan Karim differentiated their Institute with land area, infrastructure, number of buildings, number of students, activity centre, etc.
This is not the criteria, criteria of a good Institute should be foreign affiliations, graduates working in the industry, published papers by the students and teachers, qualified faculty but nothing exist at IoBM now.
Conclusion:
Some of you people may not agree to what I have written about the Institute, but believe me whatever I have written above are just my feelings. I stayed at the Institute for 5 long years, I feel the sense of belonging. I have written to make them realize, not to humiliate someone. If by any means someone gets offended then I AM SORRY.